Mix together apple cider vinegar, vegetable oil, salt, tamarind and garam masala in a zip-lock bag. Add the lamb shanks to the marinade and refrigerate for 8 hours to overnight.
Remove lamb shanks from marinade and place on foil lined baking sheet. Season all sides with kosher salt and bake at 450F for 15-20 minutes until all sides are browned. Save the marinade juices.
Combine 1 chopped onion, garlic, ginger, cherry tomatoes and water in a food processor and process until smooth. Put aside and keep cool.
Combine cayenne pepper, paprika, cinnamon, cumin, dried mustard and black pepper in bowl and set aside.
Melt ghee in a stock pot and stir in the rest of chopped onions. Cook until well browned (20-30 minutes).
Once browned, add spices to onion and cook until fragrant (1-2 minutes).
Pour saved marinade into stock pot and stir in tomato-onion mixture and brown sugar, bring to a simmer.
Add lamb shanks to stock pot, cover, and cook on low for 3-4 hours (turn lamb shanks occasionally).
Remove meat from bone with fork and remove bones. Serve over basmati rice garnished with cilantro.